Skip to content

Southern Fried Science

Over 15 years of ocean science and conservation online

  • Home
  • About SFS
  • Authors
  • Support SFS

A different perspective on the CITES disaster

Posted on April 7, 2010 By David Shiffman 2 Comments on A different perspective on the CITES disaster
Conservation

Lots has been written about the recent failure of CITES to protect marine species. Most of it focuses on blaming countries like Japan and China for putting commerce ahead of science and conservation. However, SCUBA operator and blogger Mike Da Shark has a different perspective- he criticizes the NGOs who advocated for conservation.

I definitely recommend reading the entire article here, but here are some quotes:

“All I get to see are the continued ramblings of the pundits slamming the Japanese and depicting unhelpful doomsday scenarios – and lemme tell you: I am not impressed!
Ocean Death Panel? Sushi-Cide? Tunapocalypse? What’s this, a high school poetry contest to complement the pathetic home movies?”

“Here, it appears, a motley uncoordinated naïve and clueless group of amateurs paid themselves a trip to Doha in order to protest, pontificate and vociferate – and by those metrics alone, the output has been impressive indeed!
Not however the end result: Zilch, Zero, Nana de Nada!”

”
I say, there has to be a moment of accountability after a failure of this dimension.
It’s time for those righteous and self-congratulatory folks to stop whining, to climb off their high horses and to have a hard look into the mirror – and yes, if they dare doing so, what they will see is a bunch of total and utter losers!
Time for the Director of Conservation Strategies to acknowledge that the “strategy”, if ever there was one, sucked; time for the Campaign Manager to realize that her “managerial skills” were pathetically inadequate and the campaign, a total fiasco; time for everybody who made the trip on other people’s money to tell them how much the debacle cost and to explain why going to Doha was a good idea in the first place and why the public should continue to send money to finance those useless exercises; time for replacing the failed managers and for abandoning the failed strategies in favor of new, pragmatic approaches with a chance of success”

“The lesson to be learned is that the pro faction needs to be better prepared, better coordinated and more ruthless – and possibly also more charming!”

I see what Mike is saying and I agree with some of it. By any measure, the marine  conservation NGOs at CITES failed to achieve their goals, and we definitely we need a new strategy.

However, I know several NGO representatives who went to Doha, and I must object to Mike calling them a “motley uncoordinated naïve and clueless group of amateurs”. Just as calling the Japanese representatives mean names won’t help anything, calling NGO representatives mean names won’t help anything.

Many new strategies are being proposed, but as of now I am a fan of NGOs forming a united front at meetings like CITES.

~WhySharksMatter

Share this:

  • Click to share on Bluesky (Opens in new window) Bluesky
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Click to share on Threads (Opens in new window) Threads
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
  • Click to share on Mastodon (Opens in new window) Mastodon

Related

Tags: CITES

Post navigation

❮ Previous Post: 365 days of Darwin: April 7, 2010
Next Post: 365 days of Darwin: April 8, 2010 ❯

You may also like

Conservation
Commercial Interests Trump Endangered Species
March 22, 2010
Conservation
Shark conservation is not off to a good start at CITES
March 17, 2010
Science
Traveling with Samples: the impossible journey
January 10, 2011
Conservation
CITES update: Bluefin and crocodiles and polar bears? Oh my!
March 18, 2010

2 thoughts on “A different perspective on the CITES disaster”

  1. RTSea says:
    April 7, 2010 at 5:52 pm

    David:
    I too can agree with the substance of what Mike is saying and also agree with your position regarding descriptions. Unfortunately, the blogosphere is ripe with language that can tweak the noses of many and that simply polarizes everything.

    But Mike is dead-on that conservation groups must realize that they are up against powerful forces with very aggressive, sophisticated, and well-funded strategies.

    I did a post on my blog today that looks at the fundamental sense of self-preservation in many of our hallowed institutions and how it can override issues like conservation. We must be determined and we must be smarter than we have been.

    Richard Theiss/RTSea
    http://rtseablog.blogspot.com

  2. WhySharksMatter says:
    April 8, 2010 at 11:22 am

    Do you have any thoughts on how we can be smarter?

Comments are closed.

Recent Popular Posts

Shark of Darkness: Wrath of Submarine is a fake documentaryShark of Darkness: Wrath of Submarine is a fake documentaryAugust 10, 2014Michelle Jewell
My "Follow ocean science and conservation experts on Bluesky and Instagram" assignmentMy "Follow ocean science and conservation experts on Bluesky and Instagram" assignmentNovember 19, 2024David Shiffman
Deep-sea Mining: It’s science fiction, until it isn’t.Deep-sea Mining: It’s science fiction, until it isn’t.May 14, 2025Andrew Thaler
Here's what I teach my students about finding jobs in marine biology and conservationHere's what I teach my students about finding jobs in marine biology and conservationApril 10, 2024David Shiffman
Sustainable Seafood, Endangered Species, and Jaws: Some upcoming talks and panelsSustainable Seafood, Endangered Species, and Jaws: Some upcoming talks and panelsMay 8, 2025David Shiffman
Our favorite sea monsters – Ningen (#4)Our favorite sea monsters – Ningen (#4)September 7, 2010Andrew Thaler
What can the funniest shark memes on the internetz teach us about ocean science and conservation?What can the funniest shark memes on the internetz teach us about ocean science and conservation?November 8, 2013David Shiffman
I turned my woodshop into a personal solar farm.I turned my woodshop into a personal solar farm.June 21, 2021Andrew Thaler
Alberta, Canada is the proud owner of the largest man-made pyramid on the planetAlberta, Canada is the proud owner of the largest man-made pyramid on the planetOctober 16, 2012Andrew Thaler
We Were Wrong About Megalodon: lessons learned from 10 years combating fake science in popular mediaWe Were Wrong About Megalodon: lessons learned from 10 years combating fake science in popular mediaMarch 4, 2024Andrew Thaler
Subscribe to our RSS Feed for updates whenever new articles are published.

We recommend Feedly for RSS management. It's like Google Reader, except it still exists.

Southern Fried Science

  • Home
  • About SFS
  • Authors
  • Support SFS


If you enjoy Southern Fried Science, consider contributing to our Patreon campaign.

Copyright © 2025 Southern Fried Science.

Theme: Oceanly Premium by ScriptsTown